<?xml version="1.0" standalone="no" ?>
<!DOCTYPE phase1Document PUBLIC 
   "-//Gemini 8-m Telescopes Project//DTD for astronomy phase 1//EN"
    "AstronomyPhase1.dtd" [
<!ENTITY % gemini PUBLIC 
   "-//Gemini 8-m Telescopes Project//DTD for Gemini phase 1//EN"
   "Gemini.dtd">
%gemini;
]>
<!--
  This phase1 document was produced by the Gemini Phase 1 Tool.
  Written for AstronomyPhase1 DTD version  : 1.14
  This document was created : 1999-05-21
-->
<!--
  This document contains a Gemini 8-m Telescopes Proposal (gemini)
  Gemini DTD version    : 1.6
  Semester Title        : 2000QS
  Proposal Due Date     : 2000-03-31
  Principal Investigator: PJ Puxley
  Partner Reference     : 100010001A
  Partner Ranking       : 22
  Gemini Reference      : unassigned
-->
<phase1Document created="1999-05-21" lastModified="2000-02-16" dtdVersion="1.14">
  <common>
    <title>Molecular Hydrogen Excitation in Actively Star-forming Dwarf Galaxies</title>
    <abstract>We propose to observe a small sample of weak-continuum , dwarf galaxies to investigate the excitation of molecular hydrogen in massive star-forming complexes.  In the usable fraction of our previous allocation we were able to observe one of our targets, NGC5461.  This dataset unambiguously shows that the gas is excited in low density photo-dissociation regions, contrary to the widespread assumption in the literature that the H2 in galaxies is predominantly shock excited.  The weakness of the dwarf galaxy continua permits detection of the higher level H2 transitions which are essential to determine the gas excitation and relative contributions of thermal and UV-excited gas.</abstract>
    <scienceJustification>
      <embeddedText>Background
H2 Observations of Galaxies
  A number of studies of molecular hydrogen and its excitation in galaxies have been made over the last decade (e.g. Joseph et al. 1984; Puxley, Hawarden &amp; Mountain 1988, 1990; Moorwood &amp; Oliva 1990;
Kawara &amp; Taniguchi 1993; van der Werf et al. 1993).  Early indications from low spatial and spectral resolution H2 line ratios that the gas was always shock excited were challenged by parallel theoretical developments showing that in dense, warm photo-dissociation regions heated by UV-photons the low-lying (and brightest) transitions could be thermalised.  Moreover, Puxley et al. (1990) argued that given the observed Br-gamma recombination line emission, the copious non-ionizing UV photons would be expected to produce substantial H2 emission when absorbed by molecular gas.  Indeed, the different dependences of H and H2 emission on incident UV flux provided a diagnostic of the relative spatial distributions of exciting stars and gas.  Despite these arguments, however, it remains widespread in the current literature that H2 in galaxies is shock excited (by supernova remnants and stellar outflows), although these studies are invariably without detection or reliable analysis of the critical higher level line fluxes.
  One of the principal difficulties in determining accurate fluxes for H2 lines above the lowest v=1-0 transitions is the strength of the underlying stellar continuum and the presence of metal absorption features in the cool stellar atmospheres.  Even with very high S/N data, local variations in stellar population and element abundance produces systematic features after subtraction of empirical or theoretical stellar templates.  This restricts the detectability in galaxies with strong continua to transitions brighter than those required to definitively determine the H2 excitation.
  The wider astrophysical context for studying H2 emission from galaxies is in understanding the interaction between massive stars and their environment (e.g. the relative importance of the excitation mechanisms, the effect of the formation of massive star clusters on the local ISM and its feedback into the star-formation process), the distribution of stars and interstellar material and the subsequent evolution of the starburst.  Paradoxically, within our own galaxy it can be difficult to establish, say, the H and H2 emission and excitation mechanisms for a single star-forming complex.  For example, although the peak H2 flux from shocks is 100 times that from the diffuse component in Orion, only by integrating over a 7 x 9 arcmin2 region is it revealed that the shocked and UV-excited luminosities are equal (Burton &amp; Puxley 1990; Usuda et al. 1996).  Observation of a galaxy provides such a census of the entire emission in a single measurement.
  During an IR spectroscopic study of several Wolf-Rayet galaxies, four lines of H2 were serendipitously detected in the nearby dwarf galaxy NGC5253 (Lumsden, Puxley &amp; Doherty 1994) : 1-0 S(1), 1-0 S(0) and marginally 3-2 S(3) and 2-1 S(1).  This observation represented the first suggestive evidence for the dominance of UV-photon excitation of H2 in at least some galaxies, now strongly supported by the spectrum of NGC5461 in M101 (Fig. 1). 
Proposed Observations
  The NGC5253 and NGC5461 observations raise several interesting questions: Is UV-excitation of H2 actually a general phenomenon in galaxies?  What are the relative fractions of UV- and thermally-excited gas?  What does the UV-excited component and hydrogen recombination line emission imply about the physical relationship of sources in the emitting region e.g. are they consistent with the models described by Puxley, Hawarden &amp;amp; Mountain (1988, 1990)?
  To address these questions we require measurements of the H2 line excitations sufficient to determine the contributions from UV irradiated low and high density gas, and from shocks.  Hence we propose observations of a sample of weak continuum, dwarf galaxies.  All of the galaxies have been detected in the 1-0 S(1) H2 transition (Doherty, Puxley, Lumsden &amp; Doyon 1995).  The weakness of the continua provides two benefits (i) a relatively large H2-to-continuum ration and (ii) weak underlying stellar absorption features.
</embeddedText>
    </scienceJustification>
    <keywords category="galactic">
      <keyword>Dark Matter</keyword>
      <keyword>Absorption Lines</keyword>
    </keywords>
    <!--
      The principal investigator and co investigators are listed here.
    -->
    <investigators>
      <pi status="phd" visiting="true">
        <name><first>PJ</first><last>Puxley</last></name>
        <contact>
          <email>ppuxley@gemini.edu</email>
          <phone>808-974-2501</phone>
          <fax>808-935-9802</fax>
        </contact>
        <site>
          <institution>Gemini Observatory Northern Operations</institution>
          <address>670 A Ohoku Place</address>
          <address>Hilo, HI 96720</address>
          <country>USA</country>
          <contact>
            <email>jpurcell@gemini.edu</email>
            <phone>808-935-9235</phone>
            <fax>808-974-2500</fax>
          </contact>
        </site>
      </pi>
      <coi visiting="true">
        <name><first>Matt</first><last>Mountain</last></name>
        <contact>
          <email>mmountain@gemini.edu</email>
          <phone>808-974-2523</phone>
          <fax>808-935-9650</fax>
        </contact>
        <institution>Gemini Observatory Northern Operations</institution>
      </coi>
      <coi visiting="false">
        <name><first>Sam</first><last>IYam</last></name>
        <contact>
          <email>sam@roe.ac.uk</email>
          <phone>520-318-8246</phone>
        </contact>
        <institution>Royal Observatory, Edinburgh </institution>
      </coi>
    </investigators>
    <!--
      The available targets are listed here.
    -->
    <targetCatalog>
      <target id="ref-0" type="science">
        <targetName>NGC5253</targetName>
	<targetBrightness>22 V</targetBrightness>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>13:37:05.12</c1>
          <c2>-31:23:13.2</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-1" type="science">
        <targetName>Haro2</targetName>
	<targetBrightness>24 V</targetBrightness>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>10:29:22.67</c1>
          <c2>54:39:30.8</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-2" type="science">
        <targetName>Haro3</targetName>
	<targetBrightness>23.2 B</targetBrightness>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>10:42:15.84</c1>
          <c2>56:13:26.0</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-3" type="science">
        <targetName>HZw40</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>05:53:04.93</c1>
          <c2>03:23:06.5</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-4" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0726501274</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>13:36:58.93</c1>
          <c2>-31:19:05.48</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-5" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0726501323</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>13:37:07.387</c1>
          <c2>-31:18:45.0</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-6" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0381600860</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>10:29:02.335</c1>
          <c2>54:44:17.34</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-7" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0381601019</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>10:28:44.474</c1>
          <c2>54:40:29.5</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-8" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0382600306</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>10:42:05.969</c1>
          <c2>56:09:32.98</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-9" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0382600254</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>10:42:26.261</c1>
          <c2>56:17:49.45</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-10" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0012100147</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>5:53:27.173</c1>
          <c2>3:23:58.45</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
      <target id="ref-11" type="wfs">
        <targetName>GSC0012100938</targetName>
        <hmsdegSystem type="J2000">
          <c1>5:53:25.073</c1>
          <c2>3:20:15.14</c2>
        </hmsdegSystem>
      </target>
    </targetCatalog>
  </common>
  <!--
    Each observatory has an observatory element starting here.
  -->
  <observatory observatoryId="gemini">
    <site>
      <institution>Gemini Observatory</institution>
      <address>670 A'Ohoku Place</address>
      <address>Hilo, HI 96720</address>
      <country>USA</country>
      <contact>
        <email>phase1@gemini.edu</email>
        <phone>808-974-2500</phone>
        <fax>808-935-9235</fax>
      </contact>
    </site>
    <!--
      The obsList ties together the targets, resources, and constraints.
    -->
    <obsList>
      <totalTime units="hours">11.0</totalTime>
      <constraintRef constraintId="ref-12"/>
      <resourceRef resourceId="geminiNorth"/>
      <resourceRef resourceId="gemHokupaa"/>
      <observation>
        <constraintRef constraintId="ref-13"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-0"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-4"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-5"/>
        <expTime units="hours">3.0</expTime>
        <expTotalTime units="hours">3.5</expTotalTime>
      </observation>
      <observation>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-1"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-6"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-7"/>
        <expTime units="hours">2.0</expTime>
        <expTotalTime units="hours">2.5</expTotalTime>
      </observation>
      <observation>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-2"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-8"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-9"/>
        <expTime units="hours">2.0</expTime>
        <expTotalTime units="hours">2.5</expTotalTime>
      </observation>
      <observation>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-3"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-10"/>
        <targetRef targetId="ref-11"/>
        <expTime units="hours">2.0</expTime>
        <expTotalTime units="hours">2.5</expTotalTime>
      </observation>
    </obsList>
    <observingMode mode="queue"/>
    <requirements>
      <staffSupport need="firstNight"/>
      <travelNeeds>none</travelNeeds>
    </requirements>
    <proposalSupport>
      <publication>Puxley, Doyon &amp; Ward (1996). The spatial distribution of stellar CO absorption in M83, ApJ, 476, 120.</publication>
      <publication>Puxley (1997). &quot;Multi-wavelength hydrogen recombination lines in the compact HII region K3-50a&quot; , Star-formation with ISO, in press.&quot;</publication>
      <publication>Harrison, Puxley, Brand &amp; Russel. &quot;Molecular hydrogen and the ortho/para ration in NGC253&quot;, MNRAS, in press.</publication>
      <publication>Puxley &amp; Skinner (1996). &quot;Search for IR positronium emission from the great annihilator&quot;, CTIO/ESO conf. on the Galactic Centre, in press. </publication>
      <publication>Lurnsden &amp; Puxley (1996). &quot;Near IR spectroscopy of the ultracompact HII region G45.12&quot;. MNRAS, 281, 493.</publication>
      <allocation>
        <allocationReference>UKIRT 97A</allocationReference>
        <awardedTime units="nights">2.0</awardedTime>
        <percentUsefulTime>100</percentUsefulTime>
        <comment>Data shown in text, paper in preparation</comment>
      </allocation>
    </proposalSupport>
    <scheduling>
      <minimumUsefulAllocation units="hours">12.0</minimumUsefulAllocation>
      <impossibleDates>
        <dateRange>
          <startDate>
            <year>2000</year><month>8</month><day>5</day>
          </startDate>
          <endDate>
            <year>2000</year><month>8</month><day>18</day>
          </endDate>
        </dateRange>
        <dateRange>
          <startDate>
            <year>2000</year><month>12</month><day>14</day>
          </startDate>
          <endDate>
            <year>2000</year><month>12</month><day>27</day>
          </endDate>
        </dateRange>
        <comment>Gemini science retreat; SPIE meeting</comment>
      </impossibleDates>
    </scheduling>
    <technicalJustification>
      <embeddedText>  K-window spectra with NIRI are requested of four weak-continuum, blue compact dwarf galaxies (NGC5253, Haro2, Haro3, IIZw40).  The giant HII region NGC5461 (in M101) previously observed provides a 'bridge' between studies of the starburst nuclei of galaxies and Orion-like complexes in our own Galaxy.

  The preferred NIRI configuration is 40l/mm grating and long camera which provides adequate spectral resolution and the wavelength coverage necessary to get accurate line ratios across the K window.  This is equivalent to the configuration used for our NGC5461 observation (Fig. 1).  (If necessary we can use the 150l/mm grating and observe a 4 grating settings to cover the ranges 2.02-2.1um, 2.09-2.17um, 2.16-2.24um and 2.23-2.31um.  At this higher resolution, the line/continuum contrast is improved by a factor of ~5 which largely offsets the increased time required to observe at 4 settings.  Taking account of calibration and other overheads, however, leads us to favour the lower resolution gratings as our preferred strategy.

  At least three lines from three vibrational bands (1-0, 2-1, 3-2) will be measured with a detection limit of 0.03 of the 1-0 S(1) line, plus individual lines from energy levels which can only be excited by UV radiation (e.g. 8-6 O(5)at ~40,000K).  From such a spectrum we will determine the relationship between column density and energy level, derive the rotational and vibrational temperatures and ortho/para ratio.  For radiative excitation we expect a high vibrational temperature (~5000K) compared with rotational temperature (~1000K) and an ortho/para ratio less than 3.  Comparison of the column density/energy level plot for the different vibrational bands will reveal any thermalisation due to collisions in a high density gas.

  The expected continuum flux density in GNC5253 is 0.5 x 10-15 W/m2/um (K ~ 14.7) is a 0.6 x 2.4 arcsec2 aperture (1-pixel slit, 4 pixels binned along the slit) assuming approximately uniform surface brightness in scaling from our previous 3 x 3 arcsec2 measurement.  The 1-0 S(1) line / continuum ration at a resolving power of l/dl = 850 is ~0.3 and we would aim to detect lines which are several percent of the continuum at 10 sigma.  Thus the continuum S/N required is 250-300, requiring an integration time of 1-2 hours.

  Similar previous observations of the rest of the sample gives expected continuum flux densities of 0.5 - 2 x 10-15 W/m2/um (K ~13.3-14.8) and 1-0 S(1) line / continuum ratios of 0.5-1.0.  The galaxies with weaker continua have larger line/continuum ratios and thus we expect similar integration times.

  The total request to observe the four targets, allowing 1 hour per target for calibration and acquisition, and 75% efficiancy on long integrations is 12 hours.
</embeddedText>
      <attachment name="Fig. 1" src="figure1.gif" type="gif"/>
    </technicalJustification>
    <!--
        The resourceList provides the selected resources for the observatory.
    -->
    <resourceList>
      <resourceCategory>
        <resourceType>Facility</resourceType>
        <resource id="geminiNorth">
          <resourceName>Gemini North</resourceName>
        </resource>
      </resourceCategory>
      <resourceCategory>
        <resourceType>Instrument</resourceType>
        <resource id="gemHokupaa">
          <resourceName>Hokupa'a + QUIRC - visiting Adaptive Optics System</resourceName>
          <resourceComp>
            <resourceCompType>Filter</resourceCompType>
            <resourceCompName>H (1.65 um)</resourceCompName>
            <resourceCompName>J (1.25 um)</resourceCompName>
            <resourceCompName>K (2.20 um)</resourceCompName>
          </resourceComp>
        </resource>
      </resourceCategory>
    </resourceList>
    <extension type="subDetails">
      <geminiSubDetailsExtension hostPartner="USA" multiplePartners="false">
        <semesterTitle>2000QS</semesterTitle>
        <semesterLimits>
          <dateRange>
            <startDate>
              <year>2000</year><month>6</month><day>1</day>
            </startDate>
            <endDate>
              <year>2001</year><month>1</month><day>31</day>
            </endDate>
          </dateRange>
        </semesterLimits>
        <dueDate>
          <date>
            <year>2000</year><month>3</month><day>31</day>
          </date>
        </dueDate>
        <geminiReferenceNumber>unassigned</geminiReferenceNumber>
        <geminiReceivedDate>
          <date>
            <year>2000</year><month>1</month><day>1</day>
          </date>
        </geminiReceivedDate>
      </geminiSubDetailsExtension>
    </extension>
    <extension type="tac">
      <geminiTACExtension>
        <partnerReferenceNumber>100010001A</partnerReferenceNumber>
        <partnerRanking>22</partnerRanking>
        <partnerRecommendedTime units="nights">4.0</partnerRecommendedTime>
        <partnerReceivedDate>
          <date>
            <year>1999</year><month>12</month><day>22</day>
          </date>
        </partnerReceivedDate>
        <partnerComment>
          <embeddedText>We think this proposal should be fully scheduled.</embeddedText>
        </partnerComment>
      </geminiTACExtension>
    </extension>
    <constraint type="observingConditions" name="Global Default" id="ref-12">
      <geminiObsConditionsConstraint imageQuality="Any" skyBackground="Any" waterVapor="Any" cloudCover="Any"/>
    </constraint>
    <constraint type="observingConditions" name="Best Conditions" id="ref-13">
      <geminiObsConditionsConstraint imageQuality="20" skyBackground="20" waterVapor="20" cloudCover="20"/>
    </constraint>
  </observatory>
</phase1Document>

